top of page
Shape of the State of Ohio white

Years of Award-Winning Insurance in Westerville, Ohio

50 Years of Award-Winning Insurance in Westerville, Ohio


Why it's important to work with a C.I.C.


C.I.C., or Certified Insurance Counselor, designation signifies that we have undergone extensive training and rigorous examinations in all key areas of the insurance industry. This includes completing five three-day institutes and passing five challenging exams. To maintain this designation, we must meet annual education requirements.

Choosing a C.I.C. means selecting an agent who is highly educated in practical insurance matters, nationally recognized for our expertise, and affiliated with the top 1% of insurance professionals in America. It's not about boasting; it's about ensuring you receive the highest standard of service. Don't settle for anything less than excellence when choosing your insurance agent.

John C. Kalmbaugh

President/Certified Insurance Counselor

Auto Insurance

Auto Coverage Tailored for You



Home Insurance

Protect Your Home and Belongings




Lawn & Garden Equipment



Luxury Motorhome in Ohio_edited.jpg

Insure Your Adventures on the Road



Installing Solar Panel_edited.png

Solar Panels Insurance for Homeowners



True Umbrella Protection

 Safeguarding Your Assets



  • Expertise in Auto, Home, Business and Surety Bonds, Motorcycle, Boat, Recreational Vehicles, Commercial Vehicles, Life, Health, Disability, Annuities, Pet Insurance and Special Risks.

  • Access to a wide selection of carriers.

  • Agency with over 150 years collective experience in a complex industry.

  • Advocate in the claims process.                                                                                                  

  • Our goal is to make sure, absolutely sure, that what you pay for is what you dare not live without!

Kalmbaugh Insurance Agency - office building

 We pickup the  phone! 

Kalmbaugh Insurance Agency Promotional Video
Play Video

- Elizabeth Carnes, Dublin

"Have always found excellent customer service and support from John at Kalmbaugh Insurance Agency. He takes a personal effort to make sure that issues get taken care of. I would not choose to look anywhere else for an insurance agent."  

Protect Your Pets
Instant Insurance Quote

Are you prepared for any unexpected medical expenses for your furry family member?

Safeco Insurance and Liberty Mutual Company now offers instant affordable pet insurance. They offer a range of coverage options.

Please try the new Safeco and Liberty Mutual pet insurance widget and fetch a quote today!

bottom of page