Our Team
We are an Independent Insurance Agency in Central Ohio. Our agents and staff have over over 150 years of combined Insurance Expertise.
Owner and Certified Insurance Counselor
John Kalmbaugh
John is coming up on an incredible 50 years as an insurance agent. He has a deeper understanding and passion for everything insurance.
+614-890-7222
IMAGE
COMING
SOON
Property & Casualty Agent
Margaret
Silvernail
Margaret is a Dublin resident and an extended family member of Kalmbaugh Insurance. Marjie is a licensed agent and loves the insurance business.
+614-890-7222
Senior Associate,
Property & Casualty Agent
Kerry
Kalmbaugh
Kerry is a licensed agent bringing real experience with insurance education to give our clients thoughtful and detailed policies.
+614-890-7222
IMAGE
COMING
SOON
Customer Service Specialist
Tonya
Mathias
Tonya is from Westerville and also an extended family member of the Kalmbaugh's. She always gives our clients the very best customer experience they deserve.
+614-890-7222
Marketing and Communications
Ian
Kalmbaugh
Ian Kalmbaugh is a marketing and video professional based in sunny Santa Monica, California.
+614-890-7222
Customer Fun Officer
Ludo
Kalmbaugh
Ludo is our youngest and most energetic team member. He thinks squirrels are cool but not overly obsessed. And always greets our customers with a smile.
+614-890-7222